Decolonising India’s Public Areas, One At A Time


In his seminal work “The Wretched of the Earth”, Frantz Fanon recounts an anecdote that highlights the psychological influence of colonialism on the colonised. He describes the emotions of inferiority and self-hatred that always come up in those that have been subjugated by international powers. This underscores the significance of dismantling colonial legacies to heal the collective psyche of a nation and restore a way of dignity and pleasure. The Union Authorities has been dismantling colonial legal guidelines and legacies separately. The newest one within the sequence is the dismantling of cantonments. By dismantling these cantonments, India not solely reclaims its public areas but in addition alerts its dedication to breaking free from the shackles of its colonial previous.

Within the aftermath of their victory over Nawab Siraj ud-Daula on the Battle of Plassey in 1757, the East India Firm established cantonments all through India, starting a legacy of colonial affect. The primary of those cantonments was based in 1765 at Barrackpore, close to Calcutta.

Christopher Cowell from Trinity School, Dublin, has made vital contributions to understanding the historical past of cantonments in India. Although his doctoral thesis, “The Cantonments of Northern India: Colonialism and the Counter City, 1765-1889,” is presently underneath embargo, his insightful essay “The Kaccha-Pakka Divide: Materials, Area and Structure within the Navy Cantonments of British India (1765-1889)” is extremely really helpful for these curious about exploring this matter additional.

Cantonments have a wealthy and diversified historical past, with their origins rooted in European navy practices. The origin of the time period might be traced again to the French phrase “canton,” which refers to a nook or district, as exemplified by the cantons in Switzerland. Initially, they served as momentary shelters for troops throughout harsh climate or when foraging was restricted. Lancelot Turpin de Crissé’s influential work, ‘An Essay on the Artwork of Conflict’, highlighted the significance of inner connectedness in cantonments because of the want for preparedness. This precept formed the event of cantonments throughout British rule in India, resulting in a versatile but constant association of navy services. Underneath Robert Clive’s affect, cantonments advanced into a novel, everlasting city advanced, showcasing the British East India Firm’s rising confidence in its means to take care of stability within the Bengal and Bihar areas.

From the very starting, cantonments had a definite system of segregation in place, separating the Europeans and the native sepoys. Clive, in a letter to the Choose Committee at Fort William (10 July 1765), emphasised on constructing new cantonments and the significance of strategically positioning forces to “defend the nation and protect the lives of males”. He argued that the buildings for Europeans must be sturdy, sturdy, and handy, contemplating the long-lasting and rising affect of the Firm within the area. Clive additionally talked about that the buildings for sepoys might be much less strong as a consequence of their higher means to deal with the native local weather due to their food plan, temperament, and structure. From the start, the ideas of kaccha and pakka buildings have been divided primarily based on race and local weather perceptions.

As cantonments proliferated, they facilitated the military’s means to take care of a level of separation from the native populations of pre-existing Indian city settlements. This was, partially, to allow efficient surveillance, guaranteeing that the Firm’s spatial safety measures maintained a “removable” high quality. This distinct separation additionally granted the military management over the interior growth inside cantonments. Consequently, the military was in a position to set up legal guidelines governing every cantonment enclave, figuring out the exclusion or differentiation of varied populations and practices inside these territories. This strategy finally strengthened the colonial technique of sustaining management and dominance over the colonised areas. Cantonments have been ruled by the Indian Cantonment Act. The legislation was notably thorough and included provisions addressing even issues like prostitution inside cantonments. The Cantonment Act (XXII of 1864) differentiated prostitutes primarily based on their affiliation with Europeans, subjecting solely these engaged with Europeans to regulatory measures.

The Cantonments Act was enacted in 1924, and the Navy Lands and Cantonments Service emerged as a Central Service within the Nineteen Forties. In an try at disengagement from a colonial previous, the title of the service was altered in 1985 from Defence Lands and Cantonments Service to the Indian Defence Estates Service. The persistence of cantonments in trendy India exemplifies a robust case of path dependency, illustrating how historic choices and occasions proceed to exert a big influence on establishments and infrastructure in former colonies to at the present time. On the time of independence, there have been 56 cantonments, with a further six established post-1947. Ajmer, the newest cantonment, was notified in 1962.

It’s essential to look at the extra benefits of ending cantonments, in addition to the plain goal of dismantling the colonial legacy.

(1) Lord Clive pioneered the technique of building distinct residential areas for the Firm’s forces, positioned simply exterior the modern city facilities and alongside vital commerce routes, such because the river Ganga. His intention was to reduce interactions between the Englishmen and the native inhabitants, guaranteeing that self-discipline throughout the forces was maintained and uncompromised. Nevertheless, through the years, because of fast urbanisation, these cantonments have more and more turn out to be built-in inside metropolis boundaries, with some even located close to metropolis facilities. This has resulted in disorganised progress within the adjoining areas because of the absence of complete growth methods. Other than this, the emergence of each formal and casual companies has contributed to unchecked waste manufacturing within the areas surrounding these cantonments. Though cantonments usually possess in depth tracts of largely unoccupied land and preserve a low inhabitants density, the encircling areas are typically densely populated. As civilian areas inside cantonments will likely be handed over to the city native our bodies, it’ll assist in the optimum utilisation of land particularly in densely populated cities like Delhi.

(2) Though cantonment boards are unbiased, they depend on close by municipal our bodies for important companies like water and sewage. Additionally, the presence of autonomous administrative frameworks hinders the planning course of, leading to suboptimal distribution and oversight of sources. Merging them with the municipal our bodies will maintain these impediments in service supply to the residents.

(3) In accordance with information from the Defence Estates Workplace, the Ministry of Defence possesses a powerful 17.99 lakh acres of land, with 1.61 lakh acres located in 62 strategically designated cantonments all through the nation. Enhancing the usage of current lands in city areas is a compelling and sensible strategy to rising their inhabitants capacities. As soon as the civilian areas throughout the cantonments are handed over to city native our bodies, it’ll assist these our bodies elevate far more income. This income is not going to simply come out of the property tax.

(4) There have been lot of restrictions for constructing or rebuilding constructions throughout the civil areas of cantonments.

234. Sanction for constructing. – No individual shall erect or re-erect a constructing on any land in a cantonment- (a) in an space, apart from the civil space, besides with the earlier sanction of the Board; (b) in a civil space, besides with the earlier sanction of the Chief Government Officer,  nor in any other case than in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter and of the foundations and bye-laws made underneath this Act referring to the erection and re-erection of buildings: Supplied that if an erected or re-erected constructing is supposed for public functions, then it shall be made accessible to and barrier free for the individuals with disabilities.

Part 235 of the Act is much more restrictive. Residents are required to offer discover if they’re planning to assemble or reconstruct a constructing – in the event that they make vital alterations, enlarge or convert a constructing’s goal, cut up or merge dwelling areas, or make adjustments that would negatively influence the constructing’s stability, security, drainage, sanitation, or hygiene. The constructing plans must also compulsorily conform to current legal guidelines and constructing by-laws. Each cantonment has its personal constructing by-laws. We discovered it tough to pay money for these by-laws over the web. Nevertheless, as one may guess, these by-laws are very restrictive. In a lot of the cantonments, one can construct on the bottom ground plus one. That is additionally one of many explanation why unlawful constructions which don’t conform to constructing by-laws have cropped up in among the cantonments. It is no shock that the tax collections of the cantonment boards are additionally very low. Thus, amalgamation with civic our bodies will assist do away with such provisions and permit residents to construct higher constructions that permit optimum utilisation of land.

(5) Prior to now fiscal 12 months, a staggering 74% of cantonments (46 out of 62) confronted price range deficits and acquired grant-in-aid from the Defence Ministry. A sum of Rs 190 crore was allotted to those struggling cantonments, and it was utilised for important growth works akin to repairs, drainage, avenue lighting, and water provide. This monetary help comes along with the income generated by cantonment boards. Although it’s a tiny portion of the general Defence price range, the query is, ought to the Defence Ministry be chargeable for funding the event of civil areas?

(6) Civilians who have been ruled by cantonment boards can lastly entry and profit from state authorities welfare schemes supplied by municipal firms and municipalities. This not solely ensures the equitable distribution of sources and companies but in addition fosters a extra inclusive setting for residents throughout the cantonments.

By dismantling these cantonments, India reclaims its public areas, integrates civilian areas with municipal our bodies, and alerts its dedication to progress towards a brighter future. The legacy of cantonments will undoubtedly persist, however their dismantling marks a vital step towards decolonisation and progress.

Bibek Debroy is the Chairman, Financial Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (EAC-PM) & Aditya Sinha is Extra Personal Secretary (Coverage & Analysis), EAC-PM.

Disclaimer: These are the private opinions of the creator.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here