Dressing vs. Stuffing: What’s the Distinction?


Turkey will get the entire consideration, however the actual hero of the Southern Thanksgiving meal is dressing, the proper savory embodiment of fall. Those that are fast to name this dish “stuffing” could also be complicated it with the same facet dish, baked contained in the empty cavity of a turkey. Whereas the ensuing product could also be flavorful, it finally lacks texture and will make a few of your extra squeamish dinner friends — and anybody from the USDA — a bit nervous. Dressing, then again, will get its personal pan, which permits for a crunchier floor to go with the smooth inside, plus the flavour bonus that comes with caramelization. Nonetheless not clear on the place to attract the road between dressing and stuffing? Learn on for a definitive information to Southern dressing.

What’s the distinction between stuffing and dressing?

In the beginning, as a result of this author is a proud Southerner, born and raised in Birmingham, Alabama, and presently dwelling in Atlanta. These of us progressives from the South acknowledge that our area’s previous has included some darkish moments, to say the least, however we’re staunch in our beliefs on the subject of foodways. Dressing is dressing, as a result of that’s what we consider.

A revised version of The Pleasure of Cooking presents this clarification: “The phrases ‘stuffing’ and ‘dressing’ are used interchangeably regardless of the occasional argument that something cooked within the fowl is stuffing and something baked individually have to be known as dressing.” The authors proceed, “Stuffing is definitely the unique title, and the time period ‘dressing’ got here from Victorian England when ‘stuffing’ was regarded as a bit unseemly.”

Lately, “stuffing” is ok if referring to a dish cooked within the turkey’s cavity. However doesn’t “dressing” make extra sense if the elements aren’t really stuffed into something aside from the diner’s face?

Spicy Southern Kitchen/Fb

Does dressing at all times embody cornbread? How is it ready?

So long as you comply with a couple of primary tips, the dish is a canvas on your personal private interpretation. A commonplace dressing, which marries cornbread, rooster inventory, eggs, celery, onion, and seasonings, could be augmented with fall staples similar to pecans, mushrooms, apples and pork sausage, or oysters. Frank Stitt, chef/proprietor of Highlands Bar & Grill, Bottega, and Chez Fon Fon in Birmingham and godfather of town’s now-buzzing culinary scene, had Southern gourmands chopping up turkey hearts and gizzards for his giblet dressing recipe lengthy earlier than anybody knew what “offal” meant.

As for the mandatory elements, John Currence, the James Beard Award-winning chef and restaurateur behind Metropolis Grocery, Bouré, Huge Unhealthy Breakfast, Snackbar, and Lamar Lounge in Oxford, Mississippi, tells Eater a selected savory profile is so as: “It wants plenty of celery, plenty of onion, and plenty and many sage to make a plain, conventional turkey dressing. With out sage it falls flat. That’s the headliner for me.”

And don’t even consider using store-bought bread crumbs. If you need good dressing, you’re making your personal cornbread. “They’ve these dehydrated cornbread crumbs — to make an actual good cornbread dressing, you’ve acquired to make your cornbread from scratch,” Currence says. “You would possibly let it sit in a single day, you would possibly crumble it a bit bit so it dries out — I like fresh-made cornbread for my dressing.”

Currence makes two variations for his household’s Thanksgiving desk, a regular cornbread for these with tamer palates and a modified tackle the oyster selection. “I’ll make an enormous pan of oyster dressing that’s filled with Pernod or some type of Anisette, cayenne, and I’ll even put a bit pureed spinach in it so it’s a bizarre type of Oysters Rockefeller-y dressing.”

Vegan Baking/Flickr

What does dressing go properly with?

Turkey, after all. However, it ought to be paired with an array of different hearty facet dishes: candy potatoes, inexperienced bean casserole, and the like. And don’t neglect the cranberry sauce, which is one other of Currence’s required Thanksgiving comestibles, though he doesn’t actually prefer it. Smothering dressing with gravy is completely high quality and left to particular person discretion, however a well-done model gained’t be dry and can rise up by itself.

Is dressing important for a correct Thanksgiving meal?

“Nicely, I don’t know,” Currence says with a not-so-subtle tone of sarcasm. “Do it’s important to have peanut butter on a peanut butter and jelly sandwich?”

Sure, it’s important. Go to 10 totally different homes serving basic Thanksgiving meals, and also you would possibly discover 10 totally different menus of facet dishes to go along with the principle attraction. However, each desk will embody some type of dressing.

“I believe it’s an integral a part of the meal because the turkey itself,” Currence says. “These are type of the one-two of the Thanksgiving meal. You possibly can’t have Thanksgiving with out it so far as the normal definition goes.”

What are some good dressing recipes?

Cornbread dressing (by way of Southern Residing)
Frank Sitt’s cornbread dressing with smoked bacon and pecans (by way of Southern Residing)
Alton Brown’s oyster dressing (by way of Meals Community)


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here